Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia have been identified as the world’s largest historical exporters of carbon dioxide (CO2) through fossil fuel exports, according to a new analysis tracking global oil, gas and coal trade since 1850.
The analysis, conducted by Carbon Brief and reviewed by The Guardian, estimates that Russia accounted for more than 70 gigatonnes of CO2 emissions from fossil fuels exported to other countries up to the end of 2025.
Saudi Arabia ranked second, with approximately 60 gigatonnes, while Australia placed third with more than 25 gigatonnes, slightly ahead of Venezuela.
The findings measure emissions based on the countries where fossil fuels were extracted rather than where they were eventually burned, offering a different perspective on national responsibility for global warming.
The approach differs from conventional emissions assessments, which generally attribute carbon pollution to the countries where fossil fuels are consumed.
Australia’s position on the list has attracted particular attention as the country presides over the 31st United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP31) in Turkey.
Fossil fuel exports account for about 40 per cent of Australia’s export economy, but the country has yet to establish a deadline for ending the production and export of these resources.
Louise Hutchins, convener of the Make Polluters Pay International Coalition, said the findings exposed contradictions in international climate negotiations, particularly as countries continue to debate funding for climate action while major fossil fuel exporters retain significant influence.
She argued that countries that accumulated wealth from fossil fuel production should contribute towards addressing the environmental damage associated with their exports.
The analysis also found that the United States and China remain more responsible for historical emissions than Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia when domestic fossil fuel consumption and imports are included alongside exports.
Meanwhile, discussions at COP31 have faced challenges over proposals for a global transition away from fossil fuels.
The 2023 COP28 agreement in Dubai called on countries to move away from fossil fuels but did not establish a specific timetable or implementation plan.
Australia presented an initial draft of a possible COP31 outcome on Monday, proposing language calling for an immediate transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems.
However, opposition from Saudi Arabia and other countries has raised doubts about whether the proposal will remain in the final agreement.
Climate Analytics, a research organisation, also released findings indicating that Australia had no clear plans to reduce its domestic fossil fuel extraction despite its leadership role at the climate conference.
According to the organisation, some coal mines approved in Australia could continue operating until 2088, decades beyond the period when countries are expected to achieve net-zero emissions.
Climate Analytics Chief Executive, Bill Hare, criticised the country’s continued approval of coal and gas projects, arguing that they contradicted its calls for stronger climate action internationally.
Saudi Arabia, however, rejected the attribution of emissions from exported oil to producing countries.
A representative of its Ministry of Energy told The Guardian that the country was responsible for approximately one per cent of historical global CO2 emissions generated within its borders.
The official argued that importing countries determine how purchased oil is used and manage the emissions resulting from its consumption.
The representative added that Saudi Arabia was taking steps to reduce emissions from its energy operations, citing research identifying its crude oil as having relatively low upstream carbon intensity.
Similarly, Friends of the Earth Chief Executive, Asad Rehman, called for a faster and adequately funded transition away from fossil fuels, urging wealthier countries to provide financial and technological support to nations most affected by climate change.
Russia and Australia were approached for comments on the findings.









